JH-Sportsline Home
      Premium Picks       Subscriptions       Free Picks       Capping Reports       Loyalty Program       Standings       Articles
Log In Here:
E-Mail Address:

Sign Up to Receive
Free Picks:

MB NHL 120x600 Jpg

MB MLB 120x600 Jpg

Home / Articles / Top 10 NFL Quarterbacks: A Comprehensive Ranking and Analysis

Top 10 NFL Quarterbacks: A Comprehensive Ranking and Analysis

By: Jeff Hochman     Date: Aug 1, 2023
Print Article   

When it comes to the NFL, quarterbacks play a crucial role in leading their teams to victory. The position of quarterback requires a unique set of skills, including strong arm strength, accuracy, decision-making abilities, and leadership qualities. This article will introduce you to Jeff’s top 10 NFL quarterbacks for the 2023 season who have consistently demonstrated their high efficiency and exceptional talent on the field. Please note that the QBR rankings posted are from the previous season of 2022.

These quarterbacks have proven themselves as some of the best in the league through their impressive statistics, numerous accolades, and ability to perform under pressure. From leading game-winning drives to making jaw-dropping throws, these players have earned their place among the elite in the NFL. The outcome of this league is often decided in the last 8 minutes of the game. A skilled quarterback can be the deciding factor in whether a team wins or loses.

Whether you're a die-hard football fan or simply interested in learning more about these exceptional athletes, this article will provide an insightful overview of the top 10 NFL quarterbacks who have left a memorable impact on America's most popular sport. Join us as we analyze the profiles of these highly skilled quarterbacks who continue to redefine what it means to be a successful leader on the football field.


1. Patrick Mahomes (Chiefs) QBR: 1 (77.6)

Patrick Mahomes is undoubtedly one of the most exceptional quarterbacks in the NFL today. Known for his impressive stats and numerous achievements, Mahomes has solidified his place among the top quarterbacks in the league. As a two-time Super Bowl winner, Mahomes has proven himself to be a force to be reckoned with on the field. His ability to lead his team to victory in high-pressure situations is a testament to his incredible talent and killer instinct.

Not only does Mahomes excel in terms of wins and championships, but he also stands out as an amazing athlete. His arm strength, accuracy, and agility make him a formidable opponent for any defense. Quarterback rankings consistently place him at or near the top due to his exceptional skills. He also gets to be coached by one of the best game-plan strategists of all time by Andy Reid. I love those State Farm Ads!

Beyond his physical abilities, Mahomes is also recognized for his leadership qualities. He has demonstrated an innate ability to rally his teammates and inspire them to perform at their best. This combination of athleticism and leadership sets him apart from many other quarterbacks in the league.

In summary, Patrick Mahomes' impressive quarterback stats, achievements, killer instinct on the field, remarkable athleticism, and exceptional leadership make him one of the most remarkable players in football today. I think he’s No. 1 on most people’s list and should win at least two more Super Bowls.

2. Joe Burrow (Bengals) QBR: 10 (58.7)

Joe Burrow is an accomplished quarterback known for his impressive stats and achievements in the world of football. His exceptional performance has earned him high rankings among quarterbacks, and he has the potential to reach another Super Bowl in his career. Burrow has that “IT” factor without coming across as being arrogant.

When it comes to quarterback stats, Burrow has consistently showcased his skills on the field. He has displayed remarkable accuracy, throwing for a high completion percentage and accumulating impressive passing yards. His ability to read defenses and make quick decisions under pressure has contributed to his success as a quarterback.

With his continued growth and development as a player, there is absolutely no doubt that Burrow will be an incredibly exciting player to watch on the field. Keep your eyes peeled for this rising star as he continues to dazzle us with his exceptional performance and pushes the boundaries of what is possible in the game of football.

Update: Burrow was carted off the field (July 27) with a calf strain which has the potential to linger. Expect Burrow to miss the entire preseason and valuable practice time. He likely would not have played in the preseason regardless of his health. Zack Taylor is from the Sean McVay coaching tree where they don’t play their first-team starters in the August. He’s still number two for me!

3. Josh Allen (Bills) QBR: 2 (71.4)

Josh Allen, the talented quarterback, has made a significant impact on the football field with his impressive stats and achievements. Known for his dual-threat abilities, Allen has proven himself to be a force to be reckoned with.

When it comes to quarterback rankings, Allen has consistently climbed the ladder in recent years. His ability to both pass and run effectively has made him a valuable asset for the Buffalo Bills. Despite having a shaky offensive line at times, Allen's agility and quick decision-making have allowed him to overcome obstacles and deliver impressive performances.

In terms of stats, Allen's numbers speak for themselves. He has showcased his arm strength by consistently throwing deep passes and making accurate throws under pressure. Additionally, his rushing ability adds another dimension to his game, making him a versatile threat on the field.

Throughout his career, Allen has garnered numerous achievements that highlight his skills as a quarterback. From leading the Bills to multiple playoff appearances to earning Pro Bowl selections, he continues to solidify himself as one of the premier quarterbacks in the league.

Josh Allen's dual-threat capabilities combined with his impressive stats and achievements make him an exciting player to watch in the world of football. Despite facing challenges such as a shaky offensive line at times, he continues to showcase resilience and talent that sets him apart from others in his position.

4. Jalen Hurts (Eagles) QBR: 4 (66.4)

Jalen Hurts, the talented quarterback, has achieved an impressive QBR rank of 4 with a percentage of 66.4. This statistic highlights his effectiveness and performance on the field as a quarterback. His high ranking in the quarterback stats demonstrates his ability to lead and make impactful plays. With his skill set as a dual-threat quarterback, he brings a unique dynamic to the game, posing a challenge for opposing defenses.

It is worth noting that reaching such a high QBR rank is no small feat. It speaks to Jalen Hurts' dedication, hard work, and commitment to improving his game. While achieving an impressive QBR rank is undoubtedly commendable, it's important to remember that individual statistics do not tell the whole story of a player's success. However, Jalen Hurts' ranking serves as evidence of his contributions on the field and positions him among some of the top quarterbacks in the league.

You have to respect this man after getting benched at halftime in the CFB Championship than transferring to Oklahoma and than reaches the Super Bowl in just his third year playing professional football. The Eagles own the No. 1 ranked offensive line at PFF once again this season. I would expect another solid season from the budding superstar.

5. Trevor Lawrence (Jaguars) QBR: 15 (54.5)

Trevor Lawrence, the highly talented quarterback, has significantly improved his performance during the second half of the 2022 season. According to the Quarterback Rating (QBR) rankings, he currently holds the 15th position with a rating of 54.5. While this ranking may not place him at the very top, it is essential to note that QBR is just one metric used to evaluate quarterbacks. It considers passing accuracy, touchdowns, interceptions, rushing ability, and more.

What stands out about Lawrence's performance is his notable improvement as the season progressed. This demonstrates his ability to adapt and grow as a quarterback. It is worth mentioning that rankings can fluctuate throughout a season based on individual game performances and overall team dynamics. As Lawrence continues to develop his skills and gain experience in professional football, it will be interesting to see how he further climbs up the quarterback rankings and solidifies his place among the league's elite players. The addition of Calvin Ridley can only help who's been stealing the show in Jags' camp.

6. Justin Herbert (Chargers) QBR: 11 (58.2)

Justin Herbert, the talented quarterback for the Los Angeles Chargers, has had an impressive season so far. As per the latest quarterback rankings, he currently holds the 11th spot with a Quarterback Rating (QBR) of 58.2. While this ranking is a testament to his skill and performance on the field, it is important to note that rankings can fluctuate throughout the season.

Despite his solid stats and achievements, some critics argue that Herbert lacks a certain "killer instinct" that top quarterbacks possess. However, it is worth considering that Herbert is still a young player in his career and has ample room for growth and development.

Another factor to consider when evaluating Herbert's performance is the absence of home field advantage. Without the support of fans in their home stadium, players like Herbert have had to adjust to playing in neutral environments or even away games without any crowd energy.

In conclusion, while Justin Herbert may currently rank 11th in quarterback ratings, it's important to recognize his potential for improvement as he continues to gain experience in the league. Additionally, external factors such as limited fan attendance can impact overall performance on the field.

7. Aaron Rogers (Jets) QBR: 26 (39.9)

In 2022, Aaron Rodgers, a highly skilled quarterback renowned for impressive stats and accomplishments, experienced his worst season with a QBR rank of No. 26. However, it is essential to consider the bigger picture. Rodgers was not content with his situation in Green Bay, and his relationship with the coach and GM was becoming strained.

Rankings in quarterback statistics can fluctuate throughout a season and are influenced by various factors such as team performance, offensive strategy, and individual player form. It's worth noting that rankings alone do not define a player's overall ability or success.

Despite last year’s struggles, Rodgers has proven himself as an exceptional quarterback over the years. He has led his team to multiple playoff appearances and emerged as a Super Bowl winner. His talent and leadership have often been recognized by fans and experts alike.

Furthermore, Rodgers' recent move to a new team brings new opportunities and challenges. This change brings a fresh attitude and motivation to succeed in a different environment. Additionally, it is commendable that he took a significant cut in salary to help his team add players, showing his commitment to building a solid roster.

In the world of sports, rankings can be subjective and can change rapidly based on performance fluctuations. Therefore, it is vital not to rely solely on rankings but instead consider an athlete's overall impact and contributions within their respective teams.

I'm looking forward to seeing how Aaron Rodgers will do with his new team as he embarks on this new chapter of his career. It will be fascinating to track his progress, and I hope he has a strong comeback season.

8. Lamar Jackson (Ravens) QBR: 9 (59.1)

Lamar Jackson, widely recognized for his exceptional running abilities, has earned a well-deserved reputation as one of the premier running quarterbacks in football. His remarkable agility and lightning-fast speed on the field have garnered attention and resulted in him being considered a force to be reckoned with. Jackson's unparalleled skill set enables him to significantly contribute to his team's offense, effectively utilizing his running prowess to create scoring opportunities and keep opposing defenses on their toes.

Regarding the talented athlete Lamar Jackson, prioritizing his health is paramount for him to deliver outstanding performances consistently. Just like any other athlete, ensuring that he remains injury-free is vital for maintaining a high level of performance but also for securing a long and prosperous career. By taking proactive measures to preserve his physical well-being, such as following a well-rounded training regimen, adopting proper recovery techniques, and seeking professional medical advice when needed, Lamar can enhance his chances of achieving both short-term success and long-term longevity in the competitive world of sports.

As he continues to develop and refine his skills, fans can expect great things from this talented player in the future. The upcoming season has high expectations for the Ravens football team. One significant change is their increased focus on passing plays. The team's strategy has shifted towards throwing the ball more frequently than in previous seasons. This adjustment means that Lamar Jackson, the team's quarterback, will play a vital role in elevating his performance in aerial attacks. He must showcase his skills and adapt to this new offensive approach to ensure the team's success throughout the season.

9. Dak Prescott (Cowboys) QBR: 12 (57.9)

It is important to remember that a quarterback's performance can vary from game to game, so relying solely on their stats may not accurately reflect their overall skill level. Although Dak Prescott of the Dallas Cowboys led the league in interceptions last year, he has consistently demonstrated a positive trend throughout his career. His ability to reach the average level of performance suggests that he has the potential for continued growth and improvement.

When it comes to interceptions, some may view them as a downfall, but it's crucial to take a step back and examine Prescott's performance as a whole. Despite this particular statistic, he has demonstrated remarkable perseverance and an unyielding dedication to improving his abilities. When evaluating his entire career, it becomes clear that Prescott's willingness to learn from his errors and adjust accordingly has played a significant role in his growth as a quarterback.

When assessing Prescott's performance, it's important to consider the quality of his offensive line. A strong line can significantly improve a quarterback's success by shielding him and giving him more opportunities to make precise throws. Furthermore, external factors like the absence of Zack Martin should be monitored. Any changes to the team or disruptions can affect how well the quarterback performs.

10. Deshaun Watson (Browns) QBR: Did Not Qualify

Although Deshaun Watson's Quarterback Rating (QBR) did not meet the requirements for official rankings in the previous season, his potential as a quarterback is not to be overlooked. After a nearly two-year absence, it's understandable that he may have needed time to shake off the rust and regain his form.

It's worth noting that Watson has the advantage of playing with a tremendous offensive line. The line is ranked No. 2 by Pro Football Focus (PFF) at the start of the season. This exceptional protection can contribute to improved quarterback performance and overall team success.

When looking at Deshaun Watson's performance, it's crucial to consider factors beyond his QBR. His leadership, accuracy, and ability to create opportunities for his team are all critical aspects to consider. With more time and experience, Watson has the potential to improve and make a significant impact on the field. Despite Houston's offensive ranking being in the bottom third, he posted impressive numbers. After closely observing Watson's performance during training camp, I am happy to report that it has been exceptional.

Follow Jeff on Twitter: @JHSPORTSLINE

Hot Streaks
•  MLB 67-53-1 (56% for +$4221) Last 121
•  NFL 153-94-7 (62% for +$21057) Last 254
•  NFL 386-284-19 (58% for +$23590) Last 689
•  NBA 216-191-8 (54% for +$620) Last 415
•  All Leagues 703-537-26 (57% for +$51084) Last 1266
•  All Leagues 2115-1779-80 (55% for +$54869) Last 3974
•  NCAAF 49-29-3 (63% for +$10815) Last 81
•  All Leagues 811-605-32 (58% for +$54553) Last 1448
•  All Leagues 975-722-40 (58% for +$58345) Last 1737
•  NHL 271-182-5 (60% for +$21203) Last 458
•  NHL 282-196-5 (59% for +$20908) Last 483
•  NFL 216-138-7 (62% for +$22515) Last 361
•  All Leagues 1038-797-40 (57% for +$56575) Last 1875
•  NHL 180-130-2 (59% for +$17148) Last 312
•  All Football 176-113-10 (61% for +$27776) Last 299

XB MLB 120x600 Jpg

MB HORSES 120x600 Jpg

©Copyright 1998-2024 JHSportsLine. All rights reserved. No portion of JHSportsLine.com may be duplicated, redistributed or manipulated in any form.